top of page

Fact Check Friday- “Supreme Court decides Abortion Pills are Safe"

This weeks claim...

The Supreme Court says abortion pills are safe.


What Just Happened?

Yesterday the Supreme Court rejected a Texas case challenging the FDA's approval of the commonly prescribed abortion pill medication called mifepristone. The media headlines that followed applauded the court's "unanimous upholding of abortion rights" and the high court's ruling that "approves access to mifepristone abortions." But the SCOTUS decision was far from an affirmation of the drug or "reproductive rights." Instead, the jurors unanimously decided that the plaintiff simply lacked Article III standing to challenge FDA’s actions regarding the regulation of mifepristone. The plaintiff in this case was the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, a pro-life medical group. They were represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom. To establish standing, a plaintiff must demonstrate (i) that she has suffered or likely will suffer an injury in fact, (ii) that the injury likely was caused or will be caused by the defendant, and (iii) that the injury likely would be redressed by the requested judicial relief. See the ruling here.

 

The nine Justices did not rule on the safety of mifepristone or on

the FDA standards for use. They simply ruled on the standing of the plaintiff.


The wording of the ruling leaves open the possibility that another plaintiff, including one who could show direct injury or a “sufficient likelihood of future injury” could successfully bring the case in the future. So sadly, we must wait until more injuries are reported, more deaths are reported, and more women are harmed by the drug now used for more than 60% of all abortions.


We're resending the Fact Check Friday blog from February 2 that

challenges the claim that abortion pills are safe and provides the basis for the arguments made by the plaintiff in this case. Thanks for reading and sharing Fact Check Friday blogs.


Are Abortion Pills Safe?

What they say.

Planned Parenthood can’t seem to say enough about how safe abortion pills are, “Safe and effective,” “Safe and simple,” “Safe and super common,” are phrases repeated throughout their website. The FDA, the Association of American Medical Colleges, and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) all agree, it’s really really safe…really. (The studies cited however are from 2012. And remember that these groups all have something to gain from the growing abortion industry.) The real-life stories and most current 2023 statistics don’t always support the claims of this “safe and simple” procedure. 


Let’s take a closer look. What exactly is the abortion pill?

Often called Medication Abortion, the abortion pill is actually a combination of chemicals intended to end a pregnancy. Two chemicals are administered in the form of a series of pills, Mifepristone and Misoprostol, which within 48 hours, end the life of an unborn human being. Mifepristone blocks the pregnancy hormone, progesterone, from being absorbed by the growing pregnancy, while Misoprostol causes uterine contractions that expel the growing baby.



The drug was initially intended for pregnancy up to 10 weeks, but that safeguard has been relaxed by the FDA to allow medication abortion up to 14 weeks. (Alarmingly, the 2022 Pennsylvania abortion report shows medication abortions through 24 weeks—6 months into a pregnancy.) Non-physicians can now dispense the drugs, and only one office visit is required, which may be replaced by a telehealth visit. Physicians are no longer required to report non-fatal adverse effects. And, in 2021, the FDA further loosened safeguards authorizing mail-order abortions which further separates women from actual healthcare. The United States Supreme Court will be reviewing a case in coming months that addresses the issue of these FDA deregulations. The court case, The FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, has moved through the lower courts which have overwhelmingly agreed that the rollback of restrictions on the abortion pill is harmful and can put women at catastrophic risk for complications. 


But is it safe?

The procedure is essentially a DIY abortion completed at home leaving a woman alone and with little access to pre and post abortion care. Mifepristone’s packaging instructions clearly advises women to consult an ultrasound to determine the gestational age of the baby before administering the drug, yet clinics, pharmacies, and online sales websites fail to provide this vital service.


By promoting medical abortion, big pharmaceutical companies are now cashing in while women are further separated from genuine health care. Promotion of these “self-managed” abortions and “pills by mail” ignore widely acknowledged health protections like medical screening, informed consent, and parental involvement for minors. Without an ultrasound, many women cannot confidently determine if they are within the number of weeks gestation to safely use these pills. The baby is expelled, usually in the toilet. Cramping, pain, and excessive bleeding are common and to be expected. The details for determining if the “contents of the uterus” have passed are spelled out (in very graphic detail) here:



While chemical abortions are increasing in Pennsylvania, the number of reported complications from abortions are increasing as well. There were over 469 reported complications from abortion in 2022, a 43% increase from the previous year. The number of complications has tripled in the last 5 years and the 2022 number is the highest recorded in decades. In the absence of a doctor’s care, abortion pills are simply not safe. Nationally, Mifepristone has been associated with dozens of deaths and hundreds of life-threatening complications that we know of. Expanding “abortion care” has been preferred over women’s health. 


Key Take-Aways

The Supreme Court did not rule on the safety of mifepristone or on the FDA standards for use. They simply ruled on the standing of the plaintiff.

  1. The abortion pill is a series of chemicals administered early in a pregnancy and can be dispensed by non-physician personnel and via tele-health.

  2. Abortion Pills can be ordered online and sent discreetly to any mailbox or dorm room without the recipient ever seeing a doctor. Women complete the abortion at home, alone.

  3. The abortion pill, or medication abortion now accounts for over 55% of the abortions in the state.

  4. The number of abortion pill complications has tripled in the past 5 years.

4 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page